More Questions than Answers in Tesoro’s North Dakota Oil Spill
North Dakota, long known for its cattle ranches and open spaces, has recently become one of the oil and gas industry’s most prized (and profitable) possessions, thanks to the advent of fracking. However, the price of oil and gas industry development is paid in destruction to the environment and strains to the regulatory framework meant to protect the public from a reckless industry, as Tesoro’s massive oil spill attests.
Documents from an open records request by Greenpeace have uncovered that Tesoro, a fracking giant based in San Antonio:
Possibly knew their pipeline was dangerously weak
Tesoro ran tests on the pipeline that ruptured more than 2 weeks before the spill was discovered.
A robot, known as a “smart pig,” detected weaknesses in the pipeline on September 10 and 11. Tesoro claims that they did not have ample time to digest the data before the spill, but Tesoro employees on the ground tell a different story. Furthermore, once the pipeline spill was discovered, Tesoro dispatched crews to check two other sites on the pipeline for leaks, indicating they were aware of potential fail points in the pipeline. See the documents uncovered by Greenpeace here.
Did not report the spill correctly or promptly
Tesoro corp is not saying how long the pipeline has been leaking. The hole in the line was about a quarter inch in diameter, and it would have taken some time for 20,600 barrels of oil to foul a wheat field the size of seven football fields. However, when the spill was finally reported to the authorities, the quarter inch hole had already released hundreds of thousands of gallons, enough to make the Teoro spill the largest in the history of North Dakota fracking. When Tesoro did report the spill, it did not report it through the proper channels. This caused confusion with state officials, and helped keep the spill out of the public eye for weeks.
Still does not know how much oil was spilled
Tesoro has revised the amount they admit spilling multiple times since the oil spill became public, increasing the amount significantly each time. These revisions are not a surprise given that Tesoro is using an inaccurate and backward system for measuring the oil lost, that experts say doesn’t “add up”. Their current method is to roughly estimate the amount of oil it would take to cause the evident destruction, rather than measuring the amount that should have arrived at the other end of the pipeline.
Got help from regulators to “keep the problem in North Dakota”
As with other areas that have faced oil industry invasion underwritten by fracking, North Dakota’s oil infrastructure has far outpaced the state’s ability to regulate it. Fun fact, The Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA), the federal body in charge of Tesoro’s pipeline, has only 135 federal inspectors overseeing 2.6 million miles of pipeline, which means each inspector is responsible for almost enough pipe to circle the Earth.
In North Dakota, the Department of Health oversees environmental crimes such as Tesoro’s spill. Documents obtained by Greenpeace show a close relationship between regulators for the Department of Health, the North Dakota body responsible for overseeing Tesoro, and the company itself. Regulators for North Dakota’s DOH helped Tesoro call the police on people investigating the spill, and helped Tesoro “keep the problem in North Dakota,” by trying to contain leaked information.
The huge boom in oil and gas production has been driven by fracking, a controversial drilling process that has made North Dakota one of the top producing oil fields in the world. In August North Dakota produced more than 911,000 barrels of oil per day. The Tesoro spill belies the danger of under-regulated and dangerous pipelines, like the proposed Keystone XL. These pipelines enrich the few, while the risks are borne by the unfortunate people in their path.
See this video on Exxon’s oil spill in Mayflower, Arkansas for more on how oil industry disasters affect people.