CommunityMy FDLSeminal

Antiwar Clout in House, Senate and Elsewhere

There are 12 co-sponsors to Dennis Kucinich’s bill to end the Afghan war, and significantly Nancy Pelosi, the Speaker of the House, said that she wouldn’t try to block the vote, or do anything to push war funding through Congress,…
Dennis Kucinich,(D-OH); John Conyers, Jr.; (D-MI); Ron E. Paul (R-TX); Roscoe Bartlett (R-MD); Bob Filner (D-CA); Walter Jones, Jr. (R-NC); Lynn Woolsey (D-CA); Edward Whitfield (R-KY); Michael Capuano (D-MA); Timothy V. Johnson (R-IL); Raúl M. Grijalva (D-AZ); Eric Massa (D-NY); and Alan Grayson (D-FL).

Antiwar sites like antiwar activists need to get familiar with these people, and note there somewhat different perspectives in opposing the war. I hope someone could put this in the comment section, since I don’t know much about libertarians except for Ron Paul.

Besides Pelosi, John Murtha expressed meaningful doubts. Remember back in 2006 he was prevented from becoming Majority Whip because conservatives thought he was too shrill against the Iraq war. Rep. John Murtha is the head of the Defense Appropriation subcommittee, a potentially powerful position,

When it comes to the Senate, there is antiwar debate whether there is one or two Senators opposed to the war. Bernie Sanders statements are far weaker than Kucinich’s in the House,

I think Senator Arlen Specter’s opposition to the Afghan war is even stronger than Sander’s but others disagree. Specter is strongly opposed to al Qaeda, but believes that the Afghan War only empowers al Qaeda. Some peace actives think this stance represents confusion. Note he has made strong attempts to convince administration officials, especially note his handwritten comments besides his signature,
Specter Statement on the war,

Some liberal Representatives who are upset with the war don’t want to further disrupt the progressive agenda with any harsh criticism of Obama. Specter, depending on what is happening on the ground, could offer them hope not to have to criticize Obama’s integrity.

On my earlier blog post, I mentioned Specter’s background on other issues. I hope people post comments on his earlier life there,

By the way if someone wants to see how Specter deals with things, in Philly on Dec 28 Specter will hold hearing on witness intimidation,

As I pointed out earlier, the war is more likely to end not because the next President like Nixon has a so-called secret plan to end it, but because GI’s somehow rebel against spending their entire life oversees after they thought they signed for two years. I won’t repeat my comments on young people left out in the cold, with no job and shunned by such places as soup kitchens. However, if you have a young relative you don’t want to end up in the military tell them that you would prefer that they never end up with a full time job than the end up coming back home disabled, if even only mentally, from war.

Obama made very limited statements on what his goals were with the war, something about preventing the Afghan Government from being defeated by the Taliban, and there has been behind the scenes negotiations. See,

The Taliban may agree to try to turn over bin Laden, but only if the US makes assurance that it will leave anyway if they are unable to. Bin Laden could actually be dead. It would under any circumstances be hard to distinguish, between the Taliban making a real concession for peace or one that is only cosmetic. At any rate neocons who want America to have tension or be at war with a lot of Muslims and also defense contractors would say Obama sold out. And the section of the peace movement now claiming Obama is a totally fraud would have trouble coming to the defense of the peace deal. In the meantime unfortunately escalation will continue because like in Vietnam the choice, at each point, will be escalate further or get out. Somehow making life easier for those GI’s who complain about spending their entire lives in uniform, and helping unemployed youth, especially relatives, so they won’t be cornered into the army is probably the only thing that can be done in the name of militancy that won’t backfire.

For more on Specter see,

To comment on Specter history, I would prefer comment at my previous post, if it’s not too late to post,


Previous post

Frightening the horses -- in NY and SC

Next post

Everything You Need To Know About The Karzai Cabinet Reshuffle



I'm retired in Philadelphia. Non religious but there seems to be a life force that I see as more personal than is usually expressed.

I was raised a Quaker (common with Christian Jewish intermarriage back them) But my father was a total pacifist and during World War II, at the time that being so was difficult.

Upbringing included father trying not to get physical, yet still defend us kids from my harsh stepmother until she got her citizenship papers, after which they could get divorced. Been involved in peace issues since the anti-fallout shelter protests through Vietnam and Iraq.

I wrote "Greedy Little Squirrels and Lifeboat ethics,” 1977, when the Moonies were coming to America and got heavily harassed by them. I also think bin Laden is extremely dangerous like the leader of a barroom brawl, who has been manipulating this country into using the US to get Muslims angry enough to join his suicidal permanent war group. Before 9/11 young Muslims rebelled by wearing by covering their hair a little less than expected and at least winking at each other, now he changed rebellion into being militancy. The Northern Alliance would have been legitimately in charge long ago had he not baited the US into entering Afghanistan.

Obama is making a mistake in my mind with how to stop bin Laden’s dream of permanent war in a divided world but less of a mistake than most anyone else would. If due to currency collapses from out ever more expensive weapons the US stops fighting al Qaeda, then other counties will. If it ends up being Iran, the Sunni Shiite divide will be enormous. Al Qaeda is already convinced that the atheist China is a serious enemy, and the Russians have fought for brutally and inadvertently convinced far more Muslims than the US did that they considered Islam itself to be the enemy.

I never stopped supporting Jimmy Carter when everyone turned on him and I support Obama as well, but think he will have to use a lot more persuasion and less force if they aren’t going to succeed at bankrupting us. However Obama has tried less force and al Qaeda has started to respond in kind trying to limit the victim’s in the way of their primary attacks.
Back up reference to above link,

Richard Kane (Philadelphia)
(More information if you google RichardKanePA