CommunityFDL Main Blog

SCOTUS: Gilbert, Sullivan, Sotomayor and Sunlight for the Masses

This line from Gilbert & Sullivan’s H.M.S. Pinafore sums up the whole Beltway mess, doesn’t it?

I grew so rich that I was sent, by a pocket borough into Parliament. I always voted at my Party’s call, and I never thought of thinking for myself at all.

I had forgotten how much I love a Gilbert and Sullivan farce until I was reminded of them over the weekend by, of all people, Mickey Edwards, in an otherwise bland column but for the G&S reference and this:

Political theorist Bernard Crick wrote that "politics is how a free people govern themselves." Strong political parties, on the other hand, are how a free people lose that ability. Parties choose which candidates can be on the November ballot, and do so in primaries and conventions that cater to the extremes. Parties reward fealty and discourage independence. In an earlier time, before the Internet, when it was hard to get information about candidates and they had to depend on party support for campaign funds and volunteers, political parties made sense; today, they are passe, black-and-white television, remnants of a time that has passed.

There is a reason elected officials fear sunlight. Especially party leadership.

Heaven forbid the American public actually starts paying attention to all the scurrying going on in the dark nooks and crannies and underneath all those shady rocks. Things like this:

This report from NPR’s Nina Totenberg contains a fairly remarkable piece of news: So determined to block Sonia Sotomayor, the first Latina ever nominated to the Supreme Court, McConnell took the unprecedented step of getting the NRA to do his dirty work.

One top aide to GOP leader McConnell confirmed that McConnell, at a meeting of conservative groups, asked the NRA about scoring the Sotomayor vote as a key vote hostile to gun rights. The aide conceded that in asking the question, McConnell was promoting an unusual step that the NRA then took.

You have to wonder how it is going to play in the Hispanic community around the country that the Republicans were so diametrically opposed to the nomination of Sotomayor, the Supreme Court nominee with the longest resume in nearly a century, that they called upon the NRA to twist Senators’ arms — even though they knew they didn’t have the votes to stop her nomination.

I smell 2010 electoral kabuki posturing, and not just because weird billboards have been cropping up along highways here in WV offering free bumper stickers that talk lovingly of guns, bibles and lower taxes, but gripe about "illegals."

Fool and his money and all that rot aside given that its some wingnutty business doing the advertising, it’s awfully early for this sort of posturing, isn’t it? Especially when it’s bass ackwards and stupid as all get out given the demographics involved.

Digby is sensing something similar:

It occurs to me that they are seeing something much more devastating in their numbers than just losing the Hispanic vote of the future. It seems they must be afraid of losing the white working class. Assuming they are behaving rationally (which is assuming a lot) the only logical reason they could have for ginning up all this racial animosity is if they feel the need to secure their base with the old tried and true racial resentment.

Except… then there’s this. Nothing like the smell of stoking loony anti-Christ fear, is there? (I so wish I were kidding.)

Who wants a dog whistle?

The Sotomayor debate and floor vote could happen as early as Tuesday. But the level of crazy? It’s already over the top, down the hill and into a fricking ditch, isn’t it?

Christy Hardin SmithCommunity

SCOTUS: Gilbert, Sullivan, Sotomayor And Sunlight For The Masses

This line from Gilbert & Sullivan’s H.M.S. Pinafore sums up the Beltway whole mess, doesn’t it?

I grew so rich that I was sent, by a pocket borough into Parliament. I always voted at my Party’s call, and I never thought of thinking for myself at all.

I had forgotten how much I love a Gilbert and Sullivan farce until I was reminded of them over the weekend by, of all people, Mickey Edwards, in an otherwise bland column but for the G&S reference and this:

Political theorist Bernard Crick wrote that "politics is how a free people govern themselves." Strong political parties, on the other hand, are how a free people lose that ability. Parties choose which candidates can be on the November ballot, and do so in primaries and conventions that cater to the extremes. Parties reward fealty and discourage independence. In an earlier time, before the Internet, when it was hard to get information about candidates and they had to depend on party support for campaign funds and volunteers, political parties made sense; today, they are passe, black-and-white television, remnants of a time that has passed.

There is a reason elected officials fear sunlight. Especially party leadership.

Heaven forbid the American public actually starts paying attention to all the scurrying going on in the dark nooks and crannies and underneath all those shady rocks.  Things like this:

This report from NPR’s Nina Totenberg contains a fairly remarkable piece of news: So determined to block Sonia Sotomayor, the first Latina ever nominated to the Supreme Court, McConnell took the unprecedented step of getting the NRA to do his dirty work.

One top aide to GOP leader McConnell confirmed that McConnell, at a meeting of conservative groups, asked the NRA about scoring the Sotomayor vote as a key vote hostile to gun rights. The aide conceded that in asking the question, McConnell was promoting an unusual step that the NRA then took.

You have to wonder how it is going to play in the Hispanic community around the country that the Republicans were so diametrically opposed to the nomination of Sotomayor, the Supreme Court nominee with the longest resume in nearly a century, that they called upon the NRA to twist Senators’ arms — even though they knew they didn’t have the votes to stop her nomination.

I smell 2010 electoral kabuki posturing, and not just because weird billboards have been cropping up along highways here in WV offering free bumper stickers that talk lovingly of guns, bibles and lower taxes, but gripe about "illegals."

Fool and his money and all that fundraising rot aside given that its some wingnutty business doing the advertising, it’s awfully early for this sort of posturing, isn’t it?  Especially when it’s bass ackwards and stupid as all get out given the demographics involved. (more…)

Previous post

FDL Action: Whip It! Day 40

Next post

SCOTUS: Gilbert, Sullivan, Sotomayor and Sunlight for the Masses

Christy Hardin Smith

Christy Hardin Smith

Christy is a "recovering" attorney, who earned her undergraduate degree at Smith College, in American Studies and Government, concentrating in American Foreign Policy. She then went on to graduate studies at the University of Pennsylvania in the field of political science and international relations/security studies, before attending law school at the College of Law at West Virginia University, where she was Associate Editor of the Law Review. Christy was a partner in her own firm for several years, where she practiced in a number of areas including criminal defense, child abuse and neglect representation, domestic law, civil litigation, and she was an attorney for a small municipality, before switching hats to become a state prosecutor. Christy has extensive trial experience, and has worked for years both in and out of the court system to improve the lives of at risk children.

Email: reddhedd AT firedoglake DOT com