CommunityFDL Main Blog

The House of Representatives Validated Edward Snowden

Snowden was right. The NSA could only behave how they did by hiding from the democratic oversight everything in our government should be subjected to.

On Thursday the House of Representatives voted overwhelmingly for a bill to reform the National Security Agency’s bulk collection of phone records.

On its merits it is a pretty bad bill. The bill was gutted at the last minute, making it only a shade of what was originally proposed. But the fact that Congress even felt the need to vote for a plan to “reform” the NSA is a validation of Edward Snowden.

Snowden acted because he believed the American people would not support what was being done in their name. He thought the NSA was only able to engage in a massive expansion of power because the decisions were made in secret, separate from the democratic process of checks and balances which are supposed to govern everything in this country.

Once the NSA’s behavior was made public Congress felt compelled by the electorate to try to “fix” it, even if this fix is a mostly a superficial bandage.

Snowden was right. The NSA could only behave how they did by hiding from the democratic oversight everything in our government should be subjected to.

This first action is very weak but, it is the byproduct of strong public pressure for change. More will come if regular people make it clear these scraps won’t placate them.

Photo by thierry ehrmann under Creative Commons license

CommunityFDL Action

The House of Representatives Validated Edward Snowden

Snowden was right. The NSA could only behave how they did by hiding from the democratic oversight everything in our government should be subjected to.

On Thursday the House of Representatives voted overwhelmingly for a bill to reform the National Security Agency’s bulk collection of phone records.

On its merits it is a pretty bad bill. The bill was gutted at the last minute, making it only a shade of what was originally proposed. But the fact that Congress even felt the need to vote for a plan to “reform” the NSA is a validation of Edward Snowden.

Snowden acted because he believed the American people would not support what was being done in their name. He thought the NSA was only able to engage in a massive expansion of power because the decisions were made in secret, separate from the democratic process of checks and balances which are supposed to govern everything in this country.

Once the NSA’s behavior was made public Congress felt compelled by the electorate to try to “fix” it, even if this fix is a mostly a superficial bandage.

Snowden was right. The NSA could only behave how they did by hiding from the democratic oversight everything in our government should be subjected to.

This first action is very weak but, it is the byproduct of strong public pressure for change. More will come if regular people make it clear these scraps won’t placate them. (more…)

Previous post

Hilarious Anti-China U.S. Propaganda Video Smoked by Online Ad

Next post

Over Easy: Is the New Google Glass Looking At You?

Jon Walker

Jon Walker

Jonathan Walker grew up in New Jersey. He graduated from Wesleyan University in 2006. He is now living in the Washington DC area. He created a politics and policy blog, The Walker Report (http://jwalkerreport.blogspot.com/).